Alan Gould
Pacific Planetarium Association
Berkeley, California
Rosemary Walling
Pacific Planetarium Association
Juneau, Alaska
How Planetarians’ Zoom Seminars Got Started
In the Fall of 2018, when Alan Gould assumed the role of Pacific Planetarium Secretary/Treasurer, he started a number of new initiatives to bring PPA into the 21st century. It included annual notices to members for membership renewal (actually a pre-19th century concept), a new website, a PPA Google Group, starting of digital financing (allowing members to renew membership online), and launching of monthly Planetarians’ Zoom Seminars (PZSs). He says that the motivation from the seminars came from a desire to extend communication among planetarians beyond the annual conferences of PPA and biennial conferences of IPS.
PZSs have been happening on the last Friday of each month ever since November 2018. Each seminar is recorded and archived for the enjoyment and appreciation of anyone who could not attend in person. Seminar topics and presenters are wide-ranging, and the recordings constitute a significant body of professional development material for planetarians.
Organizing the PZSs is not overly burdensome, but not trivial either. Candidate presenters must be contacted and encouraged. For a presenter to get on the schedule, they need only provide a date and time that’s convenient for them, a catchy title, brief description, and a 1 to 3 sentence bio about who they are and where they work.
Pre-seminar Steps
Announcement of a particular month’s PZS happens near the beginning of the month and goes out at least to PPA Google Group, Dome-L group, and Dome Dialogues Facebook group. A “Zoom test” with the presenter is usually done a few days before the actual PZS day to identify any technical issues that might arise and make sure the presenter remembers their commitment and is willing to have their seminar recorded.
During the Seminar
Hosting a PZS entails starting up the Zoom session, starting the recording (to cloud and to computer), introducing the presenter, watching the chat for questions and comments that need to be conveyed to the presenter, and at the end, thanking everyone for coming.
After the Seminar
Post-seminar work originally involved uploading the recording to the PPA YouTube channel and announcing its availability through the same venues as the pre-seminar announcements. The chat and any additional resources also get posted on the PZS archives.
In some ways, the hardest part of organizing is thinking of possible topics and presenters. Ideas have come from Planetarian articles, NASA events, conferences, and “the ether”. There have also been workshops, some led by Jeff Nee (previously of the NASA Education group at JPL and now with Sky-Skan), and some led by Alan based on the Planetarium Educators Workshop Guide developed at Lawrence Hall of Science, University of California Berkeley, in the 1980s.
Pandemic
In 2020, with the outbreak of COVID, PZSs became more valuable due to the inadvisability of in-person meetings and conferences. Our online seminars were unaffected, even thrived, but there was one unfortunate incident. Early in the pandemic, when there was an explosion of Zoom usage, certain young and malicious players discovered how to “zoom bomb” meetings that were not adequately protected in terms of privacy. Prior to this time, the PZSs had no privacy protection whatsoever and the Zoom links appeared on the PPA PZS web page. After our first and only very memorable zoom bomb incident, we implemented some simple privacy policies, the most important of which was not posting the zoom URL on the worldwide web.
Co-Organizer Rosemary Walling
In December of 2022, after Alan had mentioned at a previous seminar that it would be nice to have help in organizing PZSs, Rosemary Walling expressed interest and has become Co-Organizer ever since. She has expanded the post-seminar service to prepare an AI-assisted summary of each seminar. As of this writing (2026), Alan and Rosemary share all the responsibilities of organizing, hosting, and archiving the seminars.
Chrysta Ghent’s Dissertation
In 2025, Chrysta Ghent at Pennsylvania State University completed her PhD dissertation, “Online Professional Development Supporting a Community of Practice for Planetarium Professionals.” In her dissertation, the seminars were termed “Zoominars” since that was the name early in PZS history. Her dissertation is publicly available through the Penn State University libraries.
In Dr. Ghent’s conclusion there were two key findings:
- The majority of her PZS interviewees were able to put elements from Zoominars into practice (which supported participants’ educational goals) and continued conversations afterwards (which supported social goals). They reported two main reasons for attending a Zoominar: social interaction and educational content.
- Although participants did not partake in practice-related discussion during the Zoominars, many did after a Zoominar. Zoominars deepened their learning or social interactions outside of the session and contributed to a sense of professionalism. These continuing relationships led to projects and other work being done that led back to the community at large.
We are currently considering ways to make it easy to navigate and explore the now rather extensive archive of PZSs. Meantime, you are invited to peruse the PZS archives or use the Planetarians’ Zoom Seminar Archive List for an overview of all titles and speakers in the archive. And of course, please come to seminars, live!